There was something on the radio recently which brought up a study which explored the characteristic in people which make them place a higher value on something they have over something they don't have. This was illustrated in an experiment in which a group of people were asked to place a value on coffee mugs they owned while the other group, the non-owners, were asked to place a value on the same mugs. The people who were owned the coffee mugs consistently placed a much higher value on them, around $7.00, than while those who didn't own them, around $3.00.
The focus of the radio show wasn't on this endowment effect but rather it was a discussion about why Americans are so resistant to reforming their health system even though the majority of them knows it sucks. The hypothesis is that, as explained by the endowment effect, many Americans place a higher value on what flimsy health benefits they may already have over the promise of a much better system.
Now combine hero worship and the endowment effect together and you've got a potent mix of almost impenetrable, can-do-no-wrong armour. Michael Vick is a great example of this. Here's a guy who used to get off on torturing and killing dogs and never did any jail time for these sadistic acts (he pleaded not guilty to animal cruelty charges and these charges were dropped. Time served was for racketeering). Now he's up for a prestigious Ed Block Courage Award. It's utterly ironic that the Ed Block Foundation is all about bringing awareness and assisting in the prevention of child abuse and now some group of idiots wants to give this award to an animal abuser and they don't see the connection between the two.
Here's a reminder of what Vick used to do, from Bad Rap:
Jumper cables were clipped onto the ears of underperforming dogs, then, just like with a car, the cables were connected to the terminals of car batteries before lifting and tossing the shamed dogs into the water. Most of Vick's dogs were small - 40lbs or so - so tossing them in would've been fast and easy work for thick athlete arms. We don't know how many suffered this premeditated murder, but the damage to the pool walls tells a story. It seems that while they were scrambling to escape, they scratched and clawed at the pool liner and bit at the dented aluminum sides like a hungry dog on a tin can.
But for the supporters of Michael Vick and the feeble attempt to distance him from the reality of his personality with this Courage Award, which should be renamed the Discourage Award if he actually gets it, his disgusting abuse of dogs is of little concern. They've grown accustomed to worshiping Vick and don't want his hero image besmirched.
It's not my intention to pick on Americans here. The endowment effect is a human characteristic and we've got a prime example of it right here in Toronto with those who still support the ways of the unreformed and unrepentant Toronto Humane Society. The most public of such supporters is probably Peter Worthington, Toronto Sun editorialist, who continues to bolster the sinking reputation of the THS and its previous management, not by refuting any of the charges laid against them, but by the sly tactic of deflecting blame onto other agencies.
He writes, "Basically, the OSPCA resents and hates the THS because it feels it hasn't been killing enough animals." Bullshit. The implication here is bordering on the criminal and Worthington should be ashamed of himself for this near libel. He heralds the THS' reportedly low euthanasia rate as the result of some sort of noble effort without addressing at all - doesn't even mention - the multitude of claims from vets, animal care workers and volunteers concerning long term animal neglect which allegedly occurred at the THS.
Instead of providing misleading information about OSPCA euthanasia rates, I'd be impressed if he would address even just one allegation. The following is one such issue. It's just one of several provided by Johanna McNaughton, ex-THS vet, as part of a now public, sworn legal statement submitted to the Ontario Superior Court of Justice on December 21, 2009:
9. Additionally, between September 2008 and January 2009, THS would often run out of routine vaccines which were used on a daily basis. I understood from xxxx, a laboratory technician responsible for ordering the vaccines, that this was because the vaccine supplier refused to provide the vaccine until direct payment was made due to previous problems with outstanding accounts. The result of this was that animals died unnecessarily when the prompt administration of vaccine that cost only a few dollars could have saved their life.
10. It is also my opinion that many of the staff hired to fulfill veterinary technician roles at the the THS, have no formal training and are unqualified for these positions. They are administering medications without proper training/knowledge of drugs, dosing, route of administration, etc. Many animals have died as a direct result of inaccurate drug administration and incorrect procedural techniques.
14. In my experience proper requests to euthanize animals are often refused at THS, or are unduly delayed, causing unnecessary suffering to the animal. The practical effect of this policy was that many animals which would have been euthanized were not, and suffered painful deaths as a result. Other animals were forced to suffer for prolonged periods of several days to weeks before we were finally given permission to euthanize them.
15. I am aware of many specific examples which illustrate this serious problem. One cat, "Esmerelda", was brought to THS on February 10, 2009, and presented with tumours in both ears which were bleeding and painful. Biopsies were submitted and, on February 25, 2009, THS received results demonstrating that she suffered from infiltrative squamous cell carcinoma with a high rate of metastasis. This is a grave prognosis.
16. Dr. AAA, a veterinarian at THS, requested euthanasia as Esmerelda was suffering and had no prospect of recovery. This was refused by Dr. XXX.
17. Over the next week, Esmerelda developed upper respiratory infection ("URI") and anorexia. At this point the tumour was impinging on her facial nerves causing half her face to be paralyzed. Her condition continued to deteriorate and several veterinarians and veterinary technicians requested that she be euthanized. Ultimately, I asked Dr. BBB, another veterinarian at THS, if he could euthanize her, despite the fact that approval had been withheld. Dr. BBB performed the euthanasia on March 4th, 2009.
But of course Worthington won't address this because there's no way to discuss it without making the THS look bad. Nor has he addressed any of the issues brought up in this 100 page plus report here and here.
Why deal with all that nasty stuff when it's so much easier to just wave around a celebrity hero to distract people from thinking too much. But it's funny how when Worthington brings up the incident in which hero Tre rescued a dog from near death in an overheated car and in the process handcuffed and then abandoned the accused man to an unpredictable crowd, he writes, "Passersby tried to beat the man". Again, more bullshit. The passersby didn't try to beat the man, passersby did beat the man. One passerby smashed three of the guy's teeth out by bashing his head into the car. That's not trying. That's doing and that's also a fact.
Whether or not you believe the guy who owned the poor dog received his due for stupidly and neglectfully leaving his pet overheating in his car is besides the point. What's telling is how Worthington's editorial attempts to gloss over the dirty bits. It makes me wonder what else he glosses over in his attempts to divert the public discourse from what has been going on at the THS. Actually, never mind. I know what he glosses over.
The rest of Worthington's editorial is no better. He simply does not want to give up on his hero worship of the THS. He keeps busting out the well worn bafflegab of accusing the OSPCA of underhanded politics in its dealings with the THS (of course he never accuses the THS of such a thing). Worthington tries to spin all the charges, criminal and otherwise, levied against THS staff and board members into something which is merely the result of politics but what do animals left suffering and dying in their cages have anything to do with politics?
What about this, though?
Addario [THS lawyer] and others see the OSPCA using publicity to take over the THS -- something that has been building for years.
Yeah, right. If the OSPCA wanted to take over the THS, they wouldn't have to resort to using publicity. They wouldn't have to resort to anything. They could just do it. The THS is an affiliate of the OSPCA, not the other way around. The OSPCA could just unilaterally declare themselves Toronto's animal welfare agency and the THS wouldn't be able to do anything about it. Accusing the OSPCA of wanting to take over the THS is like accusing the police of wanting to take over grow-ops when they invade them.
In fact it's probably the last thing the OSPCA wants to do. That place is a freakin' mess and it's going to stay that way for who knows how long especially with the several different government agencies still investigating them, alleged financial problems, overpopulation of animals, a shitty facility, and dwindling public faith in THS' ability to provide adequate animal welfare.
The OSPCA is at the THS because they are mandated to look after animal welfare. That is their job. They have to do it. They are doing it.
But still, to the casual reader who takes Sun editorials as gospel and does little or no further research into the cruelty and obstruction of justice and impersonating a peace officer charges, these charges of bad politics at play might all appear rather plausible.
And why not? Unless you've actually witnessed it yourself, it's incredibly hard to believe that any agency with the words "humane society" could take such poor care of their animals.
The words "humane society" have got a lot of endowment effect associated with them. I'm pretty sure that if a butcher shop called itself blah blah Humane Society blah, there would be people out there who would defend its animal care practices and donate money to it.
There's really only one good way to determine just how truthful are the stories about animal neglect at the Toronto Humane Society: Go and talk to the people who used to work and volunteer there and to the people who work and volunteer there now and ask them some smart questions. Walk around and look at the dogs and cats and ask the staff what they are doing to keep the animals from going cage crazy. Ask them what they are doing to help correct bad behaviours so that those animals don't stay in cages for the rest of their lives because no one wants to adopt them. Ask them how many minutes a day the dogs get to spend with people. Ask them why there are dogs there which have been there for months and years. They may tell you that some of the dogs which have been there for years have actually been adopted out and returned a few times so ask them why there are so many failed adoptions. Ask them why they'd prefer to have dogs stay warehoused in their facility instead of being fostered out to rescues. They say they don't charge for adoptions so ask them how often they ask for a minimum "donation" for adoptions, especially puppies. Ask them why the THS doesn't spay and neuter all their animals before adopting them out. They claim to take in all animals so ask them if they actually do take in all animals. Ask them why they won't work with other animal welfare agencies. Ask them how useful it is to brag about 24/7 service when the night shift is sometimes only staffed by two people who have to look after the thousand plus animals in the facility. Ask them about management's behaviour with the public, with staff. Ask them about management's attitude towards volunteers and then talk to the volunteers to hear their side of the story. Ask them if they think it's okay for non-medical staff to make medical decisions on behalf of animals. Ask them why they don't operate a low cost spay neuter clinic. Ask them what happened to that pet food bank they used to have. Ask them why they spend so much money on lawyers for suing people. Ask them why the THS has made so many enemies.
This is why it's important to be an informed member of the THS. This is why it's important to go down to the THS and check out the animals, the staff and the facility that donor dollars are supporting. To be uninformed means allowing faults to go unchecked. It is the responsibility of the membership to stay updated on the reality of the situation at the THS and not just blindly go along with the powers that be thinking everything is okay as long as the powers that be tell them everything is okay.
The time for hero worship is over. The time to be unduly swayed by two little words, "humane" and "society", is over. It's time to dig up the truth, find out what's wrong. If the Toronto Humane Society is not reformed, it will become insignificant.
Thursday, January 14, 2010
Wednesday, January 13, 2010
Dobermans in the house
Suddenly, there are four Doberman Pinschers at Toronto Animal Services South.
Kipper is unfortunately still with TAS. It's been two months now since he first arrived. He'll make a splendid velcro dog, sticking to his owner's side, but he's hard to place because he doesn't like other dogs in close quarters and because his cage presentation has a lot to be desired. He barks at people for their attention and it's perceived as aggression so people just turn away from him and that just gets him even more desperate and aggravates the barking. His behaviour has been getting worse over the past few weeks and so TAS has been trying to find a rescue for him to go to. No takers yet.

Polo is a crazy, playful Doberman that will need someone to teach him some manners. He was taken away from his owner by police and brought to TAS.

Lex is a blue/fawn (?) Doberman and used to be called X. I guess the students who owned him thought it was a cool name. Too bad they didn't think it was cool to take him with them when they returned to whatever country they came from. They also apparently didn't think it was cool to feed him properly because he is very underweight. Otherwise, Lex is a beautiful, well-mannered dog and I don't think he'll have any problems finding more considerate owners.


The fourth Doberman, Billy, is another poor underfed thing and there is some order on its neglectful owner giving the person 72 hours to do something or other before s/he can have the dog back. Only staff are allowed to take it outside for now so I wasn't able to get a decent photo of it but we'll see where it's at in three days.

More on Billy here.
For adoption information on these and other dogs (and cats and other animals), please visit Toronto Animal Services.
Kipper is unfortunately still with TAS. It's been two months now since he first arrived. He'll make a splendid velcro dog, sticking to his owner's side, but he's hard to place because he doesn't like other dogs in close quarters and because his cage presentation has a lot to be desired. He barks at people for their attention and it's perceived as aggression so people just turn away from him and that just gets him even more desperate and aggravates the barking. His behaviour has been getting worse over the past few weeks and so TAS has been trying to find a rescue for him to go to. No takers yet.
Polo is a crazy, playful Doberman that will need someone to teach him some manners. He was taken away from his owner by police and brought to TAS.
Lex is a blue/fawn (?) Doberman and used to be called X. I guess the students who owned him thought it was a cool name. Too bad they didn't think it was cool to take him with them when they returned to whatever country they came from. They also apparently didn't think it was cool to feed him properly because he is very underweight. Otherwise, Lex is a beautiful, well-mannered dog and I don't think he'll have any problems finding more considerate owners.
The fourth Doberman, Billy, is another poor underfed thing and there is some order on its neglectful owner giving the person 72 hours to do something or other before s/he can have the dog back. Only staff are allowed to take it outside for now so I wasn't able to get a decent photo of it but we'll see where it's at in three days.

More on Billy here.
For adoption information on these and other dogs (and cats and other animals), please visit Toronto Animal Services.
Tuesday, January 12, 2010
Update on Ryker
From Ryker's new owner:

Hope you had a great holiday and are staying warm with this recent cold weather. We've been wanting to drop you a few pics of Jeffrey, Now Ryker. He's a great pup and doing well. We just took him in for his last shots and he has already gained 10 lbs in one month! We'll need a bigger house at this pace....lol. He's just started going out with the dog walker this week and is having a great time. He and Bailey are actually starting to play in the back yard. We have also enrolled him in puppy obedience starting next week. He's a very smart dog and already knows the basics.



Hope you had a great holiday and are staying warm with this recent cold weather. We've been wanting to drop you a few pics of Jeffrey, Now Ryker. He's a great pup and doing well. We just took him in for his last shots and he has already gained 10 lbs in one month! We'll need a bigger house at this pace....lol. He's just started going out with the dog walker this week and is having a great time. He and Bailey are actually starting to play in the back yard. We have also enrolled him in puppy obedience starting next week. He's a very smart dog and already knows the basics.


Monday, January 11, 2010
THS update
(A previous version of this post was released before its final edit.)
It's hard to tell where things are at with the Toronto Humane Society these days.
Adoptions are up and running again. Out of the seventy or so dogs at the facility, about twenty five were available and a few of those twenty five have already been adopted out. Let's hope they're in good, permanent homes.
What's happening with the rest of the dogs is another matter. The majority of the dogs there have either behavioural or health problems which prevent them from being put into general adoptions.
While the OSPCA was still in charge of the facility, headway was being made with regards to partnering with rescues and private fosters to find better temporary living environments for the dogs. In other words, they were being moved out of their cages at the THS into real homes.
After the court ruling which allowed the majority of the Tim Trow era THS management team to return to the building, working with rescues has, for the most part, come to a halt. The attitude is that rescues aren't to be trusted because they don't do things the THS way.
No kidding. That's why they're rescues. That's why they're not the THS. And thank God rescues don't do things the THS way. Most of the rescues I've dealt with spay and neuter ALL their dogs (except in the most extenuating circumstances like if the dogs are too young or too sick) before adopting them out. Most rescues send their dogs out to foster homes where the dogs get to live with an actual family 24/7 as opposed to getting only a few minutes of human interaction a day. And of course the great thing about that is that the dogs also don't have to spend all their time in cages going crazy from boredom and anxiety.
Is this not working with rescues a transitional thing with the THS while the new/old management gets back on its feet or are they planning to just go back to warehousing dogs indefinitely? It seems the prevailing attitude with much of the THS management is that rescues are no good for animals. Cautionary tales are heard in the hallways about how rescues take in animals only to have them neglected or abused or euthanized. This coming from an organization whose management has itself been charged with neglect and abuse and with not euthanizing animals only to have them suffer and die in their cages.
There were also plans to revamp the THS adoption site with better photos and descriptions of the dogs. The plan was to have a weekend photo shoot with professional photographers and a team of writers to work on this. All the people were ready to go. All the equipment was made available. Then the old THS management stepped in and all plans were canceled. No explanation other than they wanted to keep things the way they are.
So after all these weeks of turmoil, is it back to business as usual at the THS? Have they not learned anything from recent events?
There is a Cane Corso at the THS. Her name is Jenny. She was pregnant. A foster home had been found for her with a Cane Corso rescue where mother and pups would have been in a soft comfortable home environment with human caretakers to look after them and dote over them. Instead, the old THS management team came in last week and blocked the rescue. Jenny gave birth at the THS. The pups now get to enjoy the first few weeks of their lives in cages, exposed to the less than ideal conditions of a shelter. Jenny, instead of being able to rest and recuperate in a quiet home, now gets to spend her days in the high anxiety infused environment of the THS.
Does THS management view this retention of Jenny as some sort of victory? Are they thinking, "Whew, we almost lost her and her puppies to a home. Good thing we got back here in time to prevent that awfulness from happening."? It's like they live in some kind of massive delusion of what is right and what is wrong for the animals where everything is backwards. It reminds me of Orwell's 1984.
I sincerely hope that last week was a hiccup on the road to THS recovery. There are still efforts being made by certain individuals to get the rescues back in. It must also be said that the THS is still actively trying to find out of province placement for their questionable Pit Bull type dogs and they should be applauded for that. That is certainly a step in the right direction.
But it must go beyond just rehoming Pit Bulls. If the management at the THS want Toronto to know that they've moved on and are onto a new and better chapter, they've got to get with the times and embrace working with outside agencies in a spirit of cooperation and not paranoid suspicion and derision. It's the THS that needs to prove to the wider rescue community and the public at large that they are worthy of respect and support, not the other way around.
If the management at the THS actually think the past and present environment they've created for themselves and their animal prisoners will last, then they must live in a fantasy world. If they really think the public will just sit back and watch the THS revert back to treating animals the same way it's always treated animals and still continue to support the organization, they must be blissfully unaware of their own ignorance.
Here are two possible scenarios which might happen and neither bode well for the THS management team.
1. The old board will be replaced through a legal move or by election. The new board will fire all the senior level relics who supported the bunker mentality of the old THS and who supported the warehousing of animals in those god awful cages for months and years. The last thing a new THS needs are a bunch of throwbacks who continue to think that what they "learned" under the tutelage of Tim Trow et. al is the best they can do to contribute to the welfare of animals. It would be like a bunch of North Koreans claiming they know how to run a democracy.
2. The old board maintains its power. Everything at the THS remains the same. The public completely loses faith in the organization and stop donating. Major corporate donors stay away also because they don't want to risk their names being associated with the same old THS. Eventually, the THS becomes an even less significant player than it already is in the animal welfare community in Toronto. Toronto Animal Services and the umbrella group which represents the various rescues in the city become the major animal welfare organizations in the city.
This is pretty much the last chance the THS management has to prove that it's improved its ways. NOW is the time to show us that the THS can change for the better. NOW is not the time to continue along the same old, dead end path. NOW is not the time to cry indignation and keep railing against recent events. NOW is the time to shed delusions of grandeur and THS-knows-best and get with reality.
It's hard to tell where things are at with the Toronto Humane Society these days.
Adoptions are up and running again. Out of the seventy or so dogs at the facility, about twenty five were available and a few of those twenty five have already been adopted out. Let's hope they're in good, permanent homes.
What's happening with the rest of the dogs is another matter. The majority of the dogs there have either behavioural or health problems which prevent them from being put into general adoptions.
While the OSPCA was still in charge of the facility, headway was being made with regards to partnering with rescues and private fosters to find better temporary living environments for the dogs. In other words, they were being moved out of their cages at the THS into real homes.
After the court ruling which allowed the majority of the Tim Trow era THS management team to return to the building, working with rescues has, for the most part, come to a halt. The attitude is that rescues aren't to be trusted because they don't do things the THS way.
No kidding. That's why they're rescues. That's why they're not the THS. And thank God rescues don't do things the THS way. Most of the rescues I've dealt with spay and neuter ALL their dogs (except in the most extenuating circumstances like if the dogs are too young or too sick) before adopting them out. Most rescues send their dogs out to foster homes where the dogs get to live with an actual family 24/7 as opposed to getting only a few minutes of human interaction a day. And of course the great thing about that is that the dogs also don't have to spend all their time in cages going crazy from boredom and anxiety.
Is this not working with rescues a transitional thing with the THS while the new/old management gets back on its feet or are they planning to just go back to warehousing dogs indefinitely? It seems the prevailing attitude with much of the THS management is that rescues are no good for animals. Cautionary tales are heard in the hallways about how rescues take in animals only to have them neglected or abused or euthanized. This coming from an organization whose management has itself been charged with neglect and abuse and with not euthanizing animals only to have them suffer and die in their cages.
There were also plans to revamp the THS adoption site with better photos and descriptions of the dogs. The plan was to have a weekend photo shoot with professional photographers and a team of writers to work on this. All the people were ready to go. All the equipment was made available. Then the old THS management stepped in and all plans were canceled. No explanation other than they wanted to keep things the way they are.
So after all these weeks of turmoil, is it back to business as usual at the THS? Have they not learned anything from recent events?
There is a Cane Corso at the THS. Her name is Jenny. She was pregnant. A foster home had been found for her with a Cane Corso rescue where mother and pups would have been in a soft comfortable home environment with human caretakers to look after them and dote over them. Instead, the old THS management team came in last week and blocked the rescue. Jenny gave birth at the THS. The pups now get to enjoy the first few weeks of their lives in cages, exposed to the less than ideal conditions of a shelter. Jenny, instead of being able to rest and recuperate in a quiet home, now gets to spend her days in the high anxiety infused environment of the THS.
Does THS management view this retention of Jenny as some sort of victory? Are they thinking, "Whew, we almost lost her and her puppies to a home. Good thing we got back here in time to prevent that awfulness from happening."? It's like they live in some kind of massive delusion of what is right and what is wrong for the animals where everything is backwards. It reminds me of Orwell's 1984.
I sincerely hope that last week was a hiccup on the road to THS recovery. There are still efforts being made by certain individuals to get the rescues back in. It must also be said that the THS is still actively trying to find out of province placement for their questionable Pit Bull type dogs and they should be applauded for that. That is certainly a step in the right direction.
But it must go beyond just rehoming Pit Bulls. If the management at the THS want Toronto to know that they've moved on and are onto a new and better chapter, they've got to get with the times and embrace working with outside agencies in a spirit of cooperation and not paranoid suspicion and derision. It's the THS that needs to prove to the wider rescue community and the public at large that they are worthy of respect and support, not the other way around.
If the management at the THS actually think the past and present environment they've created for themselves and their animal prisoners will last, then they must live in a fantasy world. If they really think the public will just sit back and watch the THS revert back to treating animals the same way it's always treated animals and still continue to support the organization, they must be blissfully unaware of their own ignorance.
Here are two possible scenarios which might happen and neither bode well for the THS management team.
1. The old board will be replaced through a legal move or by election. The new board will fire all the senior level relics who supported the bunker mentality of the old THS and who supported the warehousing of animals in those god awful cages for months and years. The last thing a new THS needs are a bunch of throwbacks who continue to think that what they "learned" under the tutelage of Tim Trow et. al is the best they can do to contribute to the welfare of animals. It would be like a bunch of North Koreans claiming they know how to run a democracy.
2. The old board maintains its power. Everything at the THS remains the same. The public completely loses faith in the organization and stop donating. Major corporate donors stay away also because they don't want to risk their names being associated with the same old THS. Eventually, the THS becomes an even less significant player than it already is in the animal welfare community in Toronto. Toronto Animal Services and the umbrella group which represents the various rescues in the city become the major animal welfare organizations in the city.
This is pretty much the last chance the THS management has to prove that it's improved its ways. NOW is the time to show us that the THS can change for the better. NOW is not the time to continue along the same old, dead end path. NOW is not the time to cry indignation and keep railing against recent events. NOW is the time to shed delusions of grandeur and THS-knows-best and get with reality.
Saturday, January 9, 2010
The story of the coward, the asshole and the potty-mouthed thief
While traveling along a long stretch of highway, a coward, an asshole and a potty-mouthed thief come across a large dog lying by the side of the road. The dog appears to be breathing but is otherwise immobile.
The coward, upon seeing the dog, starts to cower and crosses to the other side of the road while keeping his eyes on the dog the whole time.
"Watch out for that beast," the coward calls out. "I'm pretty sure it's going to wake and tear you apart and try to eat you."
The asshole, seeing this as an opportunity to show up the coward, walks over to the dog and seeing that the dog does not react to his presence nor is it likely to react, shoves it with his boot. The dog makes a sound, maybe a whimper, maybe just an exhale of air from his broken ribs. Otherwise, the dog doesn't move so the asshole gives it another shove with his boot just to drive the point home whatever that point may be.
The coward, seeing that the dog did not respond to the shove from the asshole, did not lift its head even, slowly and cautiously crosses the road and walks over to the dog. The coward kicks the dog's back foot and then retreats with a squeal behind the asshole. The dog still lies prone. The coward then comes out from behind the asshole and kicks one of the dog's front feet. This time, the dog opens its eyes and looks at the coward and the coward squeals and retreats behind the asshole again.
"You're such a pussy," says the asshole laughing meanly at the coward.
"That thing looked at me," says the coward.
"So?" says the asshole and then goes over to the dog and shoves the animal's head with his boot. "It's not like it's going to do anything, you coward."
"Shut up, you asshole," says the coward and then flinches away in case the asshole feels like striking out.
The asshole just walks away, no longer interested in the dog. The coward scurries past the dog, with a thought to poke it in the eyes with a stick but thinks better of it, just in case the ugly beast decides it's hungry after all.
The potty-mouthed thief, fifty meters behind, looks up and sees that he is almost caught up with the asshole and the coward because they are examining something by the side of the road but then they take off again.
"Hey, hold up there, goddammit," he says even though no one hears him or if they do, they're not listening. He's slow because he's pulling along a heavy wagon loaded full of loot from the last house the three of them had just robbed. After the robbery, the three of them played a card game of hearts and the potty-mouthed thief had ended up with the most hearts, though not all of them, and thus he was the loser of the game making him the puller of the loot.
The loot consists of heavy items of questionable value. It's mostly silverware, if it's even silver - like how does one even tell? - and some antique looking crystal glasses and bowls and one sheepskin jacket which the asshole insisted they take - which the thief is certain the asshole will claim for himself. What a disappointment. In fact, the potty-mouthed thief doesn't think the loot is of much value at all and figures that at best they'll get a couple of hundred at the pawn shop. Subtract costs, split the remainder three ways and it almost renders the night's work a total waste of time. In fact, with all this strain on his lower back from the wagon pulling, the potty mouthed thief decides it definitely isn't worth it. Another mile of this and he'll be forced to spend his portion of the take, and more, on chiropractors and massage therapists and lots of yoga to calm his nerves.
The potty-mouthed thief is thinking these negative thoughts just as he passes by the dog lying by the side of the road. He thinks the dog is dead and is about to keep going but then he hears a whimper.
"Well, there's nothing I can fuckin' do for you, you poor shitty bastard," mumbles the potty-mouthed thief but nevertheless he stops and pulls out a bottle of water from the wagon and goes over to the dog.
There are flecks of blood by the dog's mouth and from the raspy breathing, the potty-mouthed thief is pretty sure the dog's ribs are broken, probably from being hit by a car. From the wagon, he fetches one of the stolen crystal wine glasses and unwraps the towel which had been wrapped around it for protection. He soaks the towel with water and then bends down over the dog and squeezes the water into the dog's mouth. He's not sure if this will even work but then the dog starts to slurp up the water trickling into its mouth.
It's a slow process but after a few minutes the bottle of water is empty, most of it spilled into the dirt despite the potty-mouthed thief's attentive care. He places one hand under the dog's head and cradles it. With his other hand, he gently strokes the dog's muzzle.
"Aw fuck it," the potty-mouthed thief says and he goes back to his wagon and empties out the loot and covers it up with dirt and branches. He lays out several towels on the bottom of the wagon.
He then takes the last towel, a large bath towel, pink with blue cherubs embroidered along its perimeter, and slides it underneath the dog. He tugs and wiggles the towel until finally it's spread out fully beneath the length of the dog. The potty-mouthed thief wonders if he'll be able to manage the full weight of it all but nevertheless goes ahead and grabs two corners of the towel in each hand and lifts. He heaves up the load with a grunt and a little effort. He quickly moves the dog up and into the wagon, a little afraid that the dog might thrash about from pain, but the transition goes without a hitch.
The dog acknowledges its place on this new, softer surface with a lift of its head to have a look around. Maybe the water helped, thinks the potty-mouthed thief, then he takes the sheepskin jacket and lays it over the dog. It's a bit chilly out.
The dog is a much lighter load than the loot so the potty-mouthed thief soon catches up to his companions. He explains the situation to them.
"You dumped our loot for that dog?" says the asshole. "What kind of a retard are you?"
"Look, I'll fuckin' come back later and retrieve it," says the potty-mouthed thief.
"Yeah, you'd better," says the coward. "You retard."
"Shut the fuck up," says the potty-mouthed thief.
"No, you shut the fuck up," says the asshole. "You need to dump that fucking animal and go back and get the loot."
"No fuckin way," says the potty-mouthed thief. "I'm not leaving the dog behind. That's just fuckin cruel."
"What? What did you say?" asks the asshole. "Did you just say, 'That's cruel'?"
"That's what he said," says the coward.
"I'll show you cruel," says the asshole. He walks over to the side of the road and starts to look around. He's looking for a big rock but the largest he can see is no larger than an egg.
"Goddammit," he says and he wanders further away from the road into the dry scrub. With each passing moment, the asshole's rage builds up more pressure. But that's okay, he's thinking. He starts to salivate in anticipation of the flood of orgiastic emotions he'll be savouring when he brings that big rock he's sure to find any moment now down on the head of that stinking dog. And maybe once he's done with the dog, he'll share a similar moment with that retard thief he never should have partnered up with.
The asshole stumbles out into an area free of scrub and sees exactly what he is looking for lying there on the ground not two meters away. He walks over and picks up the big rock. It's heavy and to lift it comfortably requires both the asshole's hands but he's quite satisfied with the substantial weight of it. He looks over at the road and starts walking back.
Wind the clock back two minutes and the potty-mouthed thief is watching the asshole searching. He's got a pretty good idea what the asshole is looking for and he's worried.
"Your stupid pet is going to get it now," says the coward.
"Fuck off," says the potty-mouthed thief but the coward, aroused by the possibility of bloody violence to be inflicted upon another, is not swayed.
"Your stupid pet is going get its ass kicked," says the coward.
The potty-mouthed thief wants to punch the coward in the face but holds back.
"How long have you known that fucking asshole for?" asks the potty-mouthed thief.
"Long enough," says the coward.
"Why's he always such a fucking asshole?" asks the potty-mouthed thief.
"Bad childhood," says the coward.
"I had a bad fucking childhood and I still ain't that much of a fucking asshole."
"Says you."
"Yeah, says me," says the potty-mouthed thief and then, not knowing what else to do, punches the coward in the face, breaking his nose.
The coward goes, "Uhn, un, uhh, un," and he brings his hands up to his face and touches his nose and sparks of pain are sent screaming into his brain and tears erupt and cloud up his vision and he goes, "Ahh, uhn, uh, uh."
The potty-mouthed thief grabs the handle on the wagon and starts to pull and run. The asshole, from his clearing in the scrub, sees the turn of events and starts to run as well, obliquely to the potty-mouthed thief with the intention of cutting him off somewhere up ahead and then cutting him down.
The potty-mouthed thief is slowed down by the wagon he's pulling but the asshole is slowed by the big rock he's cradling under his arm. The two of them run like this for a couple of minutes. Neither man is terribly fit. The asshole runs roughly through the scrub, sometimes almost tripping and then just recovering and the potty-mouthed thief runs somewhat like a lunatic pulling his precious red wagon. And because neither man is terribly fit, after two minutes of all out running, neither is really running anymore but rather panting and stumbling.
At one point, with the distance between them virtually unchanged, both of them stop to recover, keeping an eye on the other. A few seconds later, they both start up again.
It's apparent now to the asshole that he's not going to be able to catch up to the potty-mouthed thief if he has to run with the rock so he drops it. Somewhat rested and with arms now free and unweighted, the asshole sprints full speed at the potty-mouthed thief.
Back on the road, the potty-mouthed thief sees that the asshole is suddenly running a lot faster and realizes that it's because he's dropped the rock. The potty-mouthed thief momentarily thinks about abandoning the dog and the wagon but he's in too deep to give up now. If he doesn't end it, the asshole and the coward will catch up to him eventually and do something nasty.
"Wish me luck," he says to the dog and then he drops the wagon handle and runs into the scrub towards the asshole. They run towards each other like two mad bulls, arms and legs pumping. The scrub is quite high in spots and brushes into the potty-mouthed thief's face so he tries to keep his head tucked down.
The potty-mouthed thief is not a strategic fighter. He doesn't know what he's going to do but he knows he's got weight on his side. He's got no plan other than to smash-crash into the asshole and hopefully injure him. What comes after that, well, he hasn't given it much thought but judging from when he last saw the asshole through the scrub, the impact should come any moment now, so he'll have to make something up on the spot.
But the impact never does come.
When the potty-mouthed thief next gets a chance to see the asshole through the scrub, he sees that the asshole is no longer in front of him. The asshole has arced away and he's heading for the road, heading for the wagon. Too late, the potty-mouthed thief realizes that the asshole is running towards the dog.
The asshole gets to the road at least a good fifteen seconds ahead of the potty-mouthed thief, enough time to do some damage to that dog, even if it's with his bare hands. Revenge will be sweet. And bloody. The asshole runs over to the wagon and looks in, fists ready.
The dog isn't in the wagon. He scans around, wasting precious seconds and then he sees a lump of furry something behind some bushes. He runs over ready to kick and strike but it turns out to be the sheepskin jacket from the robbery.
There is a rustle to the right about thirty meters away and the asshole sees the dog. It's walking funny, maybe limping. The dog has seen him and it's actually coming towards him.
"Come here, doggie," yells the asshole but as soon as he does that, the dog stops. Something in his voice, perhaps, or a scent on the breeze, warns the dog to take care. The dog sits, hoping to appease the unknown human with the uncertain intentions.
The asshole advances on the dog. Twenty five meters away, twenty meters, fifteen. The dog does not move. Ten meters, five. A couple more steps, slower, and then he's there. He could reach out and grab the dog. He could do that and more, right now, and the dog still does not back away and in fact lies down and rolls on its side. It looks up at the asshole and wags its tail and for a moment the asshole wonders if he's being too much of an asshole for what he's about to do and that is the last thought he has for a very long time.
***
Later, back on the road again, the potty-mouthed thief, pulling the wagon with the dog lying in it, debates whether or not to use the last bit of bottled water to wash the dried blood off his hands. There's not a lot of blood, but still, probably enough for someone to notice. He could say it's from the dog but whatever it was that was making the dog blow blood from its nose earlier has stopped now so that might not make a believable reason.
The potty-mouthed thief stops and steps over to the dog and starts to pet it. He lets the dog smell his hand. The dog sniffs and then licks his hand. It's hard to know what's driving the dog, if it's affection or taste, but soon enough the hand is clean.
The coward, upon seeing the dog, starts to cower and crosses to the other side of the road while keeping his eyes on the dog the whole time.
"Watch out for that beast," the coward calls out. "I'm pretty sure it's going to wake and tear you apart and try to eat you."
The asshole, seeing this as an opportunity to show up the coward, walks over to the dog and seeing that the dog does not react to his presence nor is it likely to react, shoves it with his boot. The dog makes a sound, maybe a whimper, maybe just an exhale of air from his broken ribs. Otherwise, the dog doesn't move so the asshole gives it another shove with his boot just to drive the point home whatever that point may be.
The coward, seeing that the dog did not respond to the shove from the asshole, did not lift its head even, slowly and cautiously crosses the road and walks over to the dog. The coward kicks the dog's back foot and then retreats with a squeal behind the asshole. The dog still lies prone. The coward then comes out from behind the asshole and kicks one of the dog's front feet. This time, the dog opens its eyes and looks at the coward and the coward squeals and retreats behind the asshole again.
"You're such a pussy," says the asshole laughing meanly at the coward.
"That thing looked at me," says the coward.
"So?" says the asshole and then goes over to the dog and shoves the animal's head with his boot. "It's not like it's going to do anything, you coward."
"Shut up, you asshole," says the coward and then flinches away in case the asshole feels like striking out.
The asshole just walks away, no longer interested in the dog. The coward scurries past the dog, with a thought to poke it in the eyes with a stick but thinks better of it, just in case the ugly beast decides it's hungry after all.
The potty-mouthed thief, fifty meters behind, looks up and sees that he is almost caught up with the asshole and the coward because they are examining something by the side of the road but then they take off again.
"Hey, hold up there, goddammit," he says even though no one hears him or if they do, they're not listening. He's slow because he's pulling along a heavy wagon loaded full of loot from the last house the three of them had just robbed. After the robbery, the three of them played a card game of hearts and the potty-mouthed thief had ended up with the most hearts, though not all of them, and thus he was the loser of the game making him the puller of the loot.
The loot consists of heavy items of questionable value. It's mostly silverware, if it's even silver - like how does one even tell? - and some antique looking crystal glasses and bowls and one sheepskin jacket which the asshole insisted they take - which the thief is certain the asshole will claim for himself. What a disappointment. In fact, the potty-mouthed thief doesn't think the loot is of much value at all and figures that at best they'll get a couple of hundred at the pawn shop. Subtract costs, split the remainder three ways and it almost renders the night's work a total waste of time. In fact, with all this strain on his lower back from the wagon pulling, the potty mouthed thief decides it definitely isn't worth it. Another mile of this and he'll be forced to spend his portion of the take, and more, on chiropractors and massage therapists and lots of yoga to calm his nerves.
The potty-mouthed thief is thinking these negative thoughts just as he passes by the dog lying by the side of the road. He thinks the dog is dead and is about to keep going but then he hears a whimper.
"Well, there's nothing I can fuckin' do for you, you poor shitty bastard," mumbles the potty-mouthed thief but nevertheless he stops and pulls out a bottle of water from the wagon and goes over to the dog.
There are flecks of blood by the dog's mouth and from the raspy breathing, the potty-mouthed thief is pretty sure the dog's ribs are broken, probably from being hit by a car. From the wagon, he fetches one of the stolen crystal wine glasses and unwraps the towel which had been wrapped around it for protection. He soaks the towel with water and then bends down over the dog and squeezes the water into the dog's mouth. He's not sure if this will even work but then the dog starts to slurp up the water trickling into its mouth.
It's a slow process but after a few minutes the bottle of water is empty, most of it spilled into the dirt despite the potty-mouthed thief's attentive care. He places one hand under the dog's head and cradles it. With his other hand, he gently strokes the dog's muzzle.
"Aw fuck it," the potty-mouthed thief says and he goes back to his wagon and empties out the loot and covers it up with dirt and branches. He lays out several towels on the bottom of the wagon.
He then takes the last towel, a large bath towel, pink with blue cherubs embroidered along its perimeter, and slides it underneath the dog. He tugs and wiggles the towel until finally it's spread out fully beneath the length of the dog. The potty-mouthed thief wonders if he'll be able to manage the full weight of it all but nevertheless goes ahead and grabs two corners of the towel in each hand and lifts. He heaves up the load with a grunt and a little effort. He quickly moves the dog up and into the wagon, a little afraid that the dog might thrash about from pain, but the transition goes without a hitch.
The dog acknowledges its place on this new, softer surface with a lift of its head to have a look around. Maybe the water helped, thinks the potty-mouthed thief, then he takes the sheepskin jacket and lays it over the dog. It's a bit chilly out.
The dog is a much lighter load than the loot so the potty-mouthed thief soon catches up to his companions. He explains the situation to them.
"You dumped our loot for that dog?" says the asshole. "What kind of a retard are you?"
"Look, I'll fuckin' come back later and retrieve it," says the potty-mouthed thief.
"Yeah, you'd better," says the coward. "You retard."
"Shut the fuck up," says the potty-mouthed thief.
"No, you shut the fuck up," says the asshole. "You need to dump that fucking animal and go back and get the loot."
"No fuckin way," says the potty-mouthed thief. "I'm not leaving the dog behind. That's just fuckin cruel."
"What? What did you say?" asks the asshole. "Did you just say, 'That's cruel'?"
"That's what he said," says the coward.
"I'll show you cruel," says the asshole. He walks over to the side of the road and starts to look around. He's looking for a big rock but the largest he can see is no larger than an egg.
"Goddammit," he says and he wanders further away from the road into the dry scrub. With each passing moment, the asshole's rage builds up more pressure. But that's okay, he's thinking. He starts to salivate in anticipation of the flood of orgiastic emotions he'll be savouring when he brings that big rock he's sure to find any moment now down on the head of that stinking dog. And maybe once he's done with the dog, he'll share a similar moment with that retard thief he never should have partnered up with.
The asshole stumbles out into an area free of scrub and sees exactly what he is looking for lying there on the ground not two meters away. He walks over and picks up the big rock. It's heavy and to lift it comfortably requires both the asshole's hands but he's quite satisfied with the substantial weight of it. He looks over at the road and starts walking back.
Wind the clock back two minutes and the potty-mouthed thief is watching the asshole searching. He's got a pretty good idea what the asshole is looking for and he's worried.
"Your stupid pet is going to get it now," says the coward.
"Fuck off," says the potty-mouthed thief but the coward, aroused by the possibility of bloody violence to be inflicted upon another, is not swayed.
"Your stupid pet is going get its ass kicked," says the coward.
The potty-mouthed thief wants to punch the coward in the face but holds back.
"How long have you known that fucking asshole for?" asks the potty-mouthed thief.
"Long enough," says the coward.
"Why's he always such a fucking asshole?" asks the potty-mouthed thief.
"Bad childhood," says the coward.
"I had a bad fucking childhood and I still ain't that much of a fucking asshole."
"Says you."
"Yeah, says me," says the potty-mouthed thief and then, not knowing what else to do, punches the coward in the face, breaking his nose.
The coward goes, "Uhn, un, uhh, un," and he brings his hands up to his face and touches his nose and sparks of pain are sent screaming into his brain and tears erupt and cloud up his vision and he goes, "Ahh, uhn, uh, uh."
The potty-mouthed thief grabs the handle on the wagon and starts to pull and run. The asshole, from his clearing in the scrub, sees the turn of events and starts to run as well, obliquely to the potty-mouthed thief with the intention of cutting him off somewhere up ahead and then cutting him down.
The potty-mouthed thief is slowed down by the wagon he's pulling but the asshole is slowed by the big rock he's cradling under his arm. The two of them run like this for a couple of minutes. Neither man is terribly fit. The asshole runs roughly through the scrub, sometimes almost tripping and then just recovering and the potty-mouthed thief runs somewhat like a lunatic pulling his precious red wagon. And because neither man is terribly fit, after two minutes of all out running, neither is really running anymore but rather panting and stumbling.
At one point, with the distance between them virtually unchanged, both of them stop to recover, keeping an eye on the other. A few seconds later, they both start up again.
It's apparent now to the asshole that he's not going to be able to catch up to the potty-mouthed thief if he has to run with the rock so he drops it. Somewhat rested and with arms now free and unweighted, the asshole sprints full speed at the potty-mouthed thief.
Back on the road, the potty-mouthed thief sees that the asshole is suddenly running a lot faster and realizes that it's because he's dropped the rock. The potty-mouthed thief momentarily thinks about abandoning the dog and the wagon but he's in too deep to give up now. If he doesn't end it, the asshole and the coward will catch up to him eventually and do something nasty.
"Wish me luck," he says to the dog and then he drops the wagon handle and runs into the scrub towards the asshole. They run towards each other like two mad bulls, arms and legs pumping. The scrub is quite high in spots and brushes into the potty-mouthed thief's face so he tries to keep his head tucked down.
The potty-mouthed thief is not a strategic fighter. He doesn't know what he's going to do but he knows he's got weight on his side. He's got no plan other than to smash-crash into the asshole and hopefully injure him. What comes after that, well, he hasn't given it much thought but judging from when he last saw the asshole through the scrub, the impact should come any moment now, so he'll have to make something up on the spot.
But the impact never does come.
When the potty-mouthed thief next gets a chance to see the asshole through the scrub, he sees that the asshole is no longer in front of him. The asshole has arced away and he's heading for the road, heading for the wagon. Too late, the potty-mouthed thief realizes that the asshole is running towards the dog.
The asshole gets to the road at least a good fifteen seconds ahead of the potty-mouthed thief, enough time to do some damage to that dog, even if it's with his bare hands. Revenge will be sweet. And bloody. The asshole runs over to the wagon and looks in, fists ready.
The dog isn't in the wagon. He scans around, wasting precious seconds and then he sees a lump of furry something behind some bushes. He runs over ready to kick and strike but it turns out to be the sheepskin jacket from the robbery.
There is a rustle to the right about thirty meters away and the asshole sees the dog. It's walking funny, maybe limping. The dog has seen him and it's actually coming towards him.
"Come here, doggie," yells the asshole but as soon as he does that, the dog stops. Something in his voice, perhaps, or a scent on the breeze, warns the dog to take care. The dog sits, hoping to appease the unknown human with the uncertain intentions.
The asshole advances on the dog. Twenty five meters away, twenty meters, fifteen. The dog does not move. Ten meters, five. A couple more steps, slower, and then he's there. He could reach out and grab the dog. He could do that and more, right now, and the dog still does not back away and in fact lies down and rolls on its side. It looks up at the asshole and wags its tail and for a moment the asshole wonders if he's being too much of an asshole for what he's about to do and that is the last thought he has for a very long time.
***
Later, back on the road again, the potty-mouthed thief, pulling the wagon with the dog lying in it, debates whether or not to use the last bit of bottled water to wash the dried blood off his hands. There's not a lot of blood, but still, probably enough for someone to notice. He could say it's from the dog but whatever it was that was making the dog blow blood from its nose earlier has stopped now so that might not make a believable reason.
The potty-mouthed thief stops and steps over to the dog and starts to pet it. He lets the dog smell his hand. The dog sniffs and then licks his hand. It's hard to know what's driving the dog, if it's affection or taste, but soon enough the hand is clean.
Friday, January 8, 2010
Jury duty - day 5
No trials started today so no juries were selected. It's all done. My week is over.
It's definitely not something I'd want to do as a full time job, this waiting around business, but for the week, well, it was something different. It definitely gives insight as to why our justice system is so backlogged and why cases so often get thrown out of court due to institutional delays (thanks for the correction borderjack). If the rest of the systems runs as inefficiently as jury selection, it's amazing they get anything substantial done. The most surprising thing is that no one seems interested in fixing it. Oh well, that's a topic for someone else's blog.
It's definitely not something I'd want to do as a full time job, this waiting around business, but for the week, well, it was something different. It definitely gives insight as to why our justice system is so backlogged and why cases so often get thrown out of court due to institutional delays (thanks for the correction borderjack). If the rest of the systems runs as inefficiently as jury selection, it's amazing they get anything substantial done. The most surprising thing is that no one seems interested in fixing it. Oh well, that's a topic for someone else's blog.
Jury duty - day 4
Twelve jurors are required for a jury. These twelve are selected from the three groups. The groups are purely there for organization. They could just as easily go through the potential jurors one by one en masse but I guess someone somewhere along the way figured that splitting up the main pool into smaller groups was more efficient or something.
Each potential juror is asked to go into the courtroom one at a time where there is the judge, the crown prosecutor, the defence attorney, the accused, a few court personnel and any jurors already selected. The juror is asked to step into the witness box and swear to tell the truth and is then asked a question. The juror must answer the question and is then judged on it by two "triers" who had been previously selected from the same pool of possible jurors. The triers' job is to decide whether or not the potential juror can perform a juror's duties objectively. If the both triers say the potential juror is acceptable then the person is asked to step down from the witness box and look the accused in the eye. Then the crown prosecutor is asked if he finds the potential juror acceptable. If yes, then he says "acceptable". If no, he says "challenge". Then the defence attorney is asked to declare acceptable or challenge. If after this, the potential juror has been deemed acceptable by all parties, then the potential juror is now a real juror.
The morning in the jurors' lounge on the first floor was uneventful for the first couple of hours and then at about 11:30, we were called into a courtroom on the sixth floor.
While the generalities in jury selection are the same, the details vary from judge to judge. In today's case, the judge addressed us potential jurors, told us about our responsibilities and then the drawing of names commenced. Three groups of twenty five were formed. I was the fourteenth person in the second group.
My second group was escorted into another courtroom to sit and wait until we broke for lunch at about 1:00. Coming back from lunch, we heard that the first group was finished and out of those twenty five people, only four had been chosen to sit as jurors. Our group of twenty five was further divided into three groups and the ten in my group were led into another room to sit and wait while the first ten were led into the courtroom for their questioning.
A couple of voices took over the conversation in the small room, something about someone's relative being a hunter when he was a kid and was now a sniper with some police force somewhere in Ontario. Something about how when he was a baby, lying on his back he would pee and the pee would spray right into his own mouth. Something about how now he is one of the best snipers in Canada and how the peeing in the mouth was a precursor of this.
This is what I was thinking about as I entered the witness box.
"Yes, I do," I answered when asked by a court officer if I would swear to tell the truth.
The judge addressed me next and asked if I had any reasons to be excused from serving jury duty to which I said no.
The defence attorney then stood up and announced that he would ask me the question.
Now, I'm not allowed to say what the question was but I can probably say that it had an ethical foundation which only makes sense since it is a court of law, not a court of mathematics or plumbing or whatever.
I gave the court my answer in my calmest pleasedontfreakoutpleasedontfreakout voice. Meanwhile, I was still thinking about the pee pee in mouth/police sniper story.
I looked over at the two triers. They looked back at me. They consulted with each other in whispers. Then one of them looked back at me and announced, "Accept."
So I passed the first out of three.
One of the court officers then asked me to step down from the witness box and to stand on the floor of the court in front of the judge and look over at the accused. I did this. I tried to remain expressionless but some part of my brain was still thinking pee pee in mouth.
Someone asked the crown prosecutor if he wished to challenge or accept.
He looked at me and said, "Accept."
That was the second out of three. One more "accept" and I would be a juror.
Lastly, the defence counsel was asked his opinion. He looked at his pad of paper where he'd scribbled some notes down. He looked at me. He looked at his pad. He looked at me. He said, "Challenge."
It kind of felt like failing to graduate even though I'm still not sure it's something I would have wanted to graduate into but, you know, with all the build up, it was like a game where you have winners and losers and it felt like I had just lost in the third inning. I know I wasn't supposed to view it that way but part of me still did.
The other part of me was thinking thank God.
I was then led out of the courtroom and sent back down to the main jurors' lounge on the first floor where I spent the remainder of the afternoon with the rest of the losers.
Each potential juror is asked to go into the courtroom one at a time where there is the judge, the crown prosecutor, the defence attorney, the accused, a few court personnel and any jurors already selected. The juror is asked to step into the witness box and swear to tell the truth and is then asked a question. The juror must answer the question and is then judged on it by two "triers" who had been previously selected from the same pool of possible jurors. The triers' job is to decide whether or not the potential juror can perform a juror's duties objectively. If the both triers say the potential juror is acceptable then the person is asked to step down from the witness box and look the accused in the eye. Then the crown prosecutor is asked if he finds the potential juror acceptable. If yes, then he says "acceptable". If no, he says "challenge". Then the defence attorney is asked to declare acceptable or challenge. If after this, the potential juror has been deemed acceptable by all parties, then the potential juror is now a real juror.
The morning in the jurors' lounge on the first floor was uneventful for the first couple of hours and then at about 11:30, we were called into a courtroom on the sixth floor.
While the generalities in jury selection are the same, the details vary from judge to judge. In today's case, the judge addressed us potential jurors, told us about our responsibilities and then the drawing of names commenced. Three groups of twenty five were formed. I was the fourteenth person in the second group.
My second group was escorted into another courtroom to sit and wait until we broke for lunch at about 1:00. Coming back from lunch, we heard that the first group was finished and out of those twenty five people, only four had been chosen to sit as jurors. Our group of twenty five was further divided into three groups and the ten in my group were led into another room to sit and wait while the first ten were led into the courtroom for their questioning.
A couple of voices took over the conversation in the small room, something about someone's relative being a hunter when he was a kid and was now a sniper with some police force somewhere in Ontario. Something about how when he was a baby, lying on his back he would pee and the pee would spray right into his own mouth. Something about how now he is one of the best snipers in Canada and how the peeing in the mouth was a precursor of this.
This is what I was thinking about as I entered the witness box.
"Yes, I do," I answered when asked by a court officer if I would swear to tell the truth.
The judge addressed me next and asked if I had any reasons to be excused from serving jury duty to which I said no.
The defence attorney then stood up and announced that he would ask me the question.
Now, I'm not allowed to say what the question was but I can probably say that it had an ethical foundation which only makes sense since it is a court of law, not a court of mathematics or plumbing or whatever.
I gave the court my answer in my calmest pleasedontfreakoutpleasedontfreakout voice. Meanwhile, I was still thinking about the pee pee in mouth/police sniper story.
I looked over at the two triers. They looked back at me. They consulted with each other in whispers. Then one of them looked back at me and announced, "Accept."
So I passed the first out of three.
One of the court officers then asked me to step down from the witness box and to stand on the floor of the court in front of the judge and look over at the accused. I did this. I tried to remain expressionless but some part of my brain was still thinking pee pee in mouth.
Someone asked the crown prosecutor if he wished to challenge or accept.
He looked at me and said, "Accept."
That was the second out of three. One more "accept" and I would be a juror.
Lastly, the defence counsel was asked his opinion. He looked at his pad of paper where he'd scribbled some notes down. He looked at me. He looked at his pad. He looked at me. He said, "Challenge."
It kind of felt like failing to graduate even though I'm still not sure it's something I would have wanted to graduate into but, you know, with all the build up, it was like a game where you have winners and losers and it felt like I had just lost in the third inning. I know I wasn't supposed to view it that way but part of me still did.
The other part of me was thinking thank God.
I was then led out of the courtroom and sent back down to the main jurors' lounge on the first floor where I spent the remainder of the afternoon with the rest of the losers.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
